Back

One of the questions we are asked most by families is "What cruise line is best for parents and their kids ?

We have personally sailed on the Disney Cruise Line, Royal Caribbean Cruise Line, specifically their "Voyager-class" ships, and Carnival Cruise lines, all with our children. While all certainly have advantages and disadvantages, we are most impressed with the Disney Cruise Line and the Voyager-class ships of Royal Caribbean Cruise Lines.

The table below is our personal evaluation of both, side-by-side, so you can compare for yourself. Both are spectacular family ships. We have sailed the Disney Magic three times and the Voyager-class ships twice (Explorer of the Seas & Navigator of the Seas). We have just completed our third cruise on the Disney Magic and will sail the Mariner of the Seas in February 2004 and the Voyager of the Seas in October 2004.

Disney Cruise Line Voyager-class, RCCL

Staterooms

These are the largest at sea, with a particularly attractive feature of a split-bath (categories 10 & up). A sink & shower are in one half and a sink & toilet in the other. Bigger size than the older RCCL ships, smaller than DCL. Promenade view rooms are unique -- an interior room with a window overlooking the Royal Promenade

Inside

From 184 to 214 square feet From 160 - 167 square feet
Ocean view 214 square feet From 180 - 265 square feet
Balcony From 268 - 304 square feet From 173 - 277 square feet
Suites From 614 - 945 square feet From 381 - 1,188 square feet

Dining Rooms

Disney has unique rotational dining. You and your servers alternate through three very differently themed restaurants. Themes of the restaurants is excellent, especially the Animator's Palette. Menus change nightly, with several themed dinners on the 7-day cruise.

Adults-only Palo is superb. Dinner nightly and Champagne brunch. Small additional fee per person.

Main dining room is three-levels with a piano player and a very attractive grand staircase. Second and third levels have floor to ceiling windows overlooking the ocean.

One (or two on newer ships) adults-only restaurants. Portofino and Chops Grille. Small additional fee per person

Dining - Food

DCL's food has improved a lot since its inception. Our past cruise it was noticeably better, for almost all selections. Adequate variety, but not outstanding. Many choices for children, with a slightly different children's menu nightly. Quality is a bit better. More choices from adult menu. Kid's menus also available

Casual Dining

Topsiders buffet offers a good option to the formal dining, although it can seem crowded at times, depending on the number of people on your sailing..  Lunch options change daily, but breakfast is the same. Also available are burger, dogs, etc. at Pluto's Dog House, near the Mickey pool. Pinocchio's offers pizza. At times, though, they were all between meals and not serving....bummer Island Grill offers large buffet. Traffic pattern makes it seem less crowded. Many other options, including Johnny Rockets (opens at 11AM daily). Best is the Promenade Cafe, open 24 hrs with pizza, sandwiches, snacks, great desserts. More ice cream stations scattered about, and almost always open

Feature Entertainment

Fabulous Broadway style shows. Disney's shows are their strongpoint, with much more emotional attachment than a singing/dancing show. Very good shows for children. Large movie theatre (Buena Vista Theatre) is a big plus, with some first-run movies showing. For "late" diners, the main show is before dinner.

Also have family cabaret shows on many nights, usually at 7:45 PM

Very good shows, Vegas/Broadway style. Also comedians and other acts. Small theatre on Deck 2.Shows are appropriate for children, except "late night". For "late" diners, the main show is usually after diner (10:45pm). Of course, let's not forget the ice show, the only one at sea. It is an excellent show, offered multiple times throughout the week, so everyone can see it.

Kids Program

Largest area at sea, 15,000 Sq. ft. Five age groups. Parents given pagers in case they need to be contacted. Open late, with no added charge. Also have a nursery for kids under 3--great option. Most days, you have the option of letting the kids eat meals with the kids counselors. Kids program also stays open on port days and even moves to Castaway Cay.

Large area, not as large as DCL. Four age groups. No pagers for parents. On selected nights, can eat with kids group. After 10PM, charge is $5/hr.

Teens

"The Stack" - newly developed area on the Magic. Music, TV's and a lot of noise . Not very large.

"Common Grounds" - NY style coffee bar on the Wonder

Larger area than DCL and an even larger expanded area on the Navigator & Mariner. Three separate areas, a casual area, disco and outside deck area (the entire rear of deck 12)

Lounge Areas

"Beat Street" (Magic) or Route 66 (Wonder), for adults only at night. Has three clubs. On the Magic they are "Sessions" (light piano player music), Rockin' Bar D (variety of musical and cabaret shows), and Diversions (a sports bar / pub, with big screen TV's

 Also the Promenade Lounge on deck 4 for a casual drink and music, also for families.

More lounge areas. Some on the Royal Promenade, On some ships, there is a wine-tasting bar. Areas are spread out throughout the ship. Excellent Viking Crown Lounge on deck 14, high above everything, with a 270 degree view of the ocean.

Adult Activities

Usual cruise activities such as bingo. Also have other adult activities throughout the week, focusing on the technical aspects of the ship, the food, etc. More adult activities. Besides the usual (bingo, horse races) there are art auctions throughout the week and the casino. While not big gamblers by any means, it was a nice place to spend some time. (and a few $$ !)

Pool Areas

Three areas, Adult -- Family -- Kids. Kids area (Mickey pool) can be very crowded at times. The kids really enjoy the slide. Although nearby, the music is themed for each area. Must be 18 or older for the adult pool & whirlpools. Two pool areas (three on the Voyager/Explorer/Adventure). Plenty of deck chairs On Navigator & Mariner, there is no shallow separate kiddie pool. One pool and whirlpool is open 24 hrs.

Other On Board Activities

Vista Spa, basketball court, QuarterMaster arcade (small and can get very crowded on full ship cruises) More than any ships at sea. 9-hole miniature golf course, inline skating track, rock climbing wall, golf simulator, full-size basketball court, spa. Ice skating rink available for guests throughout the week. Very large arcade

On Board Shopping

Main shopping area has two shops. Mickey's Mates has those wonderful Disney-themed gifts. Treasure Ketch  has jewelry/collectible shop and other clothing options. Royal Promenade has extensive shops. General Store (sundries/toiletries), logo shop, jewelry, collectibles. Some ships have a Tommy Hilfiger shop also.

Itineraries

The Western Caribbean is a great itinerary. All Disney cruises stop at Castaway Cay -- the best place a ship can stop. Multiple itineraries, since there are five ships. Choose one that stops at Labadee -- second only to Castaway Cay. Adventure of the Seas leaves from San Juan and gets to islands DCL can't from Port Canaveral -- Aruba & Curacao

Embarkation

Very smooth A wait at peak boarding times, usually can board about 12 noon , give or take a few minutes. Takes a little longer, maybe due to number of guests. Try to arrive early, about 11:00 - 12:00.

Debarkation

Very flexible. Breakfast time based on dinner seating time. Debarkation after breakfast, at your convenience so long as customs has cleared the ship. We have been off of the ship and in our car (or a bus) by 8:30AM. Debarkation by color-coded luggage tags. Not as smooth or swift as DCL. TV viewing available in main theater during debarkation.

Terminal facilities

Very attractive terminal, probable "special" visit by those characters!. Check out the map of the Caribbean on the floor. Special counter for Castaway Club check-in (repeat cruisers). Parking lot adjacent. Large terminal (Miami), Special boarding area for Crown & Anchor guests with 5+ RCCL cruises. Large multi-level parking garage available right next door at $10 / day.

"Intangibles"

The Disney characters, the emotional attachment and involvement, the Disney feel, the Disney music ....... Sailing aboard the largest vessels on the oceans. Enormous variety of things to do. Great people watching along the Royal Promenade

Our Cruises

 August 2000 - 7-day Eastern Caribbean on the Disney Magic

November 2001 - 7-day Eastern Caribbean on the Disney Magic

November 2003 - 7-day Western Caribbean on the Disney Magic

August 2002 - 7-day Western Caribbean on the Explorer of the Seas

February 2003 - 7-day Eastern Caribbean on the Navigator of the Seas

February 2004 - 7-day Eastern Caribbean on the Mariner of the Seas

October 2004 - 9-day Western Caribbean on the Voyager of the Seas

 

Well, there you have it. Our unbiased comparison of two great lines and ships. What follows is some information on the ships themselves.. Enjoy. !

 

Disney Magic & Disney Wonder

Voyager of the Seas , Explorer of the Seas, Adventure of the Seas, Navigator of the Seas, Mariner of the Seas

Inaugural Voyage

        Magic - 1998 ,         Wonder - 1999

Voyager - 11/21/99 ,     Explorer 10/28/2000,    Adventure - 11/18/2001 , Navigator 11/14/2002 ,   Mariner - 11/16/2003
Length , in feet 964 1,020
Gross Weight (tons) 83,000 138,000
Capacity  (double occ. / total possible) 1,754 / 2,700 3,114 / 3,844
Top speed   22 knots
Number of Staterooms 877 1,557
inside 256 480
ocean view 237 182
balcony 384 757
inside with atrium view 0 138
Crew Size 950 1,185
     
     
     

                                                                                                              Page last modified on March 13, 2004